All       Cars       Entertainment       Gambling       Gaming       Girls       Life       Sports       Technology

Determining a Sport

Does this count?

29
July
icon + back to Sports+ 604 views+ 0 comments
 

article thumbnail
About a week ago, a judge in Connecticut determined that competitive cheerleading is not an official sport that colleges can use to meet gender requirements. My reaction upon hearing this was bravo judge, job well done. But this got me thinking about sports in general. What criteria exactly determines what is and what isn?t a sport. Now you will never find one right answer, but I?m going to do my best to help clarify that answer by laying out the criteria that I feel best defines what exactly a sport is.

The first and most obvious criterion for a sport is something that requires some sort of athletic or physical exertion while performing the sport in question. You can?t call something a sport if you aren?t moving around or doing anything involving some serious hand eye coordination. So I would like to apologize to the late Bobby Fischer, just because the International Olympic Committee considers chess a sport, doesn?t make it so. Breaking a mental sweat in my book doesn?t count as physical activity. My dad always used to crush me in chess but it wouldn?t stop me from crossing him up in a pickup basketball game. This also eliminates NASCAR, Formula 1, or racing vehicles of any kind from being considered a sport. NASCAR may be one of the most popular ?sports? in the US, but driving around in circles for five hours in a row doesn?t qualify as physical activity in my book. The only physical stress they may experience is holding back a large dump in the middle of the race. That takes some serious talent.

Second, nothing that is choreographed can ever be considered a sport. Sorry cheerleaders of the world, the bus stops here. Athleticism and hard work is only one part of what determines a sport. I?m not taking away from anything that they do, because some of it is pretty impressive, but sports are not choreographed. The wrestlers for the WWE do some pretty amazing things themselves, but I don?t see them making ESPN. This rule also goes for synchronizes swimming (which I can?t believe I even have to justify) and gymnastics of any kind that are choreographed. This goes hand in hand with another criterion of mine that says the outcome of an event, game or match cannot be determined by a judge. A third party should not be the one to determine the outcome. The people competing in the event should be the ones who control the outcome. If someone is better than me, I don?t need a judge to give me a score that lets me know this. Which leads me to my last and most controversial criterion.

For something to be considered a sport there has to be a clear winner and a clear loser. When I think of a sport, I think of two sides competing against one another until the game is over and you have a winner and a loser. When the Red Sox play the Yankees or the Saints play the Colts, there is always a winner and a looser. Something such as a Tennis tournament is acceptable because within the tournament, you have individuals squaring off where the winner advances and the loser goes home. I?m talking about winning and losing at the most basic level. This eliminates primarily all of the Olympic events such as running, swimming, diving, rowing etc. This list could go on for days. I classify these as athletic activities, because there is no question that the people who participate are tremendous athletes, however the events they are performing in don?t have true losers. There is no 2nd or 3rd place in real sports. When the Phillies lost the World Series, they didn?t stand on a podium and proudly accept a second place trophy. They accepted defeat and went home. You don?t compete against times in sports, you compete against the person or team in front of you.

TAGS
tag
Sports
tag
tag
cheerleader
tag
tag
Olympics
tag
tag
winning
tag
tag
losing
tag
tag
real sports
tag
tag
Reg Tucciarone
tag
Add a new comment

login with your menversus account
Connect with Facebook

Email address (will not be displayed)


Username




Showing oldest comments first - < FLIP >
other posts

All Eyes on U
All Eyes on U
09/09/2010 08:15 pm
Here We Go Again!
Here We Go Again!
08/02/2010 09:01 pm
World Cup Team of the Semi-Finals
World Cup Team of the Semi-Finals
07/12/2010
Women in the Locker Room
Women in the Locker Room
09/15/2010 04:04 pm
Ater Majok
Ater Majok
08/28/2010 10:45 am